• Skip to main content
Property Investments UK Logo
Skip NavigationMenu
  • About
  • Articles
    • Latest Articles
    • General Concepts
    • Property Experts
    • Local Market Analysis
    • Investment Strategies
    • Selling Property
    • Media and Press
  • Training
  • Buy a Property
  • Sell a Property
  • Mortgages
  • Create a Company
  • Contact

09/09/2020

Why a ‘One-Size-Fits-All’ Approach Should Never be Applied to Landlord Tax Planning

by Mark Alexander

Mark has been a portfolio landlord for 31 years and worked in property, finance, tax and law for 34 years.

  • Since 2009 he has gradually been doing less work and selling property in order to enjoy a much better retirement. That was always his plan.
  • He achieved financial independence in 2003 and by 2008 one of his companies ranked at #38 in The Sunday Times Profit Track 100.
  • He was a founder of the NACFB and also Property118.
  • He was also a non-exec Chairman for a Barristers Chambers until a few years ago.
  • His speciality is landlord tax and has published numerous articles on this subject.

For more information please see www.Property118.com/Tax

Prior to introducing the Section 24 legislation “restricting finance cost relief for private landlords to the basic rate of tax” in his Summer 2015 Budget, the Chancellor at that time (George Osborne) commissioned the OBR (Office of Budget Responsibility) to produce an impact report. That report suggested that 19% of all private sector residential landlords would be affected by the legislation and pay more tax. Therefore, we can deduce that circa 400,000 UK landlords have mortgages and are higher rate tax-payers.

The Property118 Tax team are specialists in advising on incorporation relief, but very few landlords actually qualify for reliefs to make a viable case to actually proceed. Therefore, it is important to note that Property118 and Cotswold Barristers also recommend a variety of other ownership structures. All recommendations are bespoke, we do not believe in a ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach.

Before I move onto some of the other solutions we recommend (and others we don’t) I will outline the profile of landlords who are more likely to be recommended to transfer their ‘whole business’ into a Limited Company in exchange for shares.

These landlords will commit at least 20 hours a week to run their established rental property businesses and meet the definition of the Partnership Act 1890, i.e. “two or more persons engaged in business with a view to profit”.  Their rental property business will comprise a minimum of 10 dwellings. That could be 10 separate houses or flats, one large property comprising 10 dwellings or even two or three properties such as student lets or HMO’s comprising 10 or more dwellings between them. All ‘partners’ will also be higher rate tax-payers. Please note this is an absolute minimum guideline.

Given that less than 5% of all UK rental property owners will meet the above criteria, this means that alternative solutions will need to be considered for the others who might well be paying more tax then is necessary.

The HMRC logo can be seen on a phone screen, sitting next to a stone

In many cases, forming a partnership with other family members will be the way forward.  Such arrangements facilitate business succession planning and opportunities for both income tax and legacy planning. This is because the profits of the rental property business can be allocated between family members to fully utilise their lower rate, tax bands. Furthermore, profit allocation is very different from drawings. A very good example of the use of a family partnership structure can be found via the article I have linked to below.

  • LLP Structure Acheives 85% Tax Reduction - CASE STUDY -

    When used correctly, Limited Liability Partnerships “LLPs” can be an excellent structure for landlords, not just for tax planning but also for the evolution of rental property…

HMRC’s manuals sate as follows:-

“There are few restrictions on who can be a partner. Both natural and artificial persons, such as companies, can be partners.

It is not a requirement of a partnership that each member is physically capable of performing the full range of the activities of the partnership business, but each must be capable of performing a part of the activities, even if that role is only to provide finance. A partner who plays no active part in the business but has contributed capital is often described as a ‘sleeping partner’.”

AND

“Spouses and civil partners can enter into a partnership with each other. Sometimes this is done for tax planning reasons as it may be advantageous for a person to share their business profits with his or her spouse to maximise the use of their personal allowances and basic rate tax bands. HMRC is unlikely to challenge such an arrangement.”

Mixed Partnerships are another structure we consider but recommend even less often than we recommend incorporation. There are several reasons for this, but the most common are:-

  1. Mortgage Lenders do not like mixed Partnerships – Paragon Mortgages criteria specifically precludes lending to them
  2. The advantages of being able to transfer income to a corporate Member of an LLP in order to facilitate a lower rate of tax on retained profits has been legislated against year after year for over a decade by HMRC
  3. Mortgage liabilities cannot be transferred to a corporate Member of an LLP without transferring the underlying assets at either a legal or beneficial ownership level.  These transfers trigger Capital Gains Tax because mortgage liabilities cannot be offset against the transfer of legal or beneficial ownership and there is no ‘incorporation relief’ either unless the ‘whole business’ is transferred and all other eligibility criteria for incorporation relief are also met.

Where a landlord intends to acquire further investment properties, we often recommend two separate solutions. This might be a family partnership for existing rental properties and a Family Investment Company for future acquisitions.

Family Investment Companies are an extremely popular structure with our clients. For further details please read the linked article below.

  • Freezer Shares and IHT Planning for Incorporated Landlords...

    Freezer shares provide an opportunity for owners of property companies to cap the value of the shares for IHT planning purposes by transferring future growth in value of the company outside their...

There can also be massive tax advantages associated with emigrating to another country, but be careful which one you pick!

I fully appreciate that moving to a different country is a huge decision to make.  Whilst this step may not be appropriate for you now, I think it is worth pointing out the benefits. They can be significant!

For example, when you are non-resident you don’t pay tax on dividends in the UK. Instead, you pay tax in your country of residence. However, some countries do not charge tax on overseas dividend income. The most tax-efficient country in Europe at the moment is Portugal under their NHR scheme. Not only do you pay no tax on UK dividend income for the first 10 years, you only pay CGT on capital gains made on UK  property since April 2015, regardless of how long you owned it for or how much it rose in value up to that date.

Dozens of landlords that Property118 has consulted have taken advantage of the planning opportunities associated with moving abroad, either before incorporating their property rental business or afterwards. Others don’t incorporate at all, they just relocate before selling up, to reduce the amount of CGT payable of course. Some landlords with particularly valuable property businesses save millions in tax just by retiring to a place in the sunshine.

Ready to Invest..?

We can give you access to a wide range of off-market property investment properties, with an average 8%+ annual yield (beating the UK's average of 3-5%, hands down). There's no commitment - all you have to do is sign up to discover what's on offer - Click below. 

Interesting, Show me More

...Or Thinking of Selling?

Investment property can be difficult to sell and the process will often leave the landlord out of pocket. We have sales-solutions for investors that estate agents simply can't include amongst the services that they can reasonably provide, with a guarantee.

Okay, Let's Have a Look

Filed Under: Property Experts

ON THIS SITE
  • Buy a Property
  • Sell a Property
  • Courses and Events
  • Property Crowdfunding
  • Blog
  • Reviews
LEGAL
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Use
  • Cookies
  • LOG IN

    Current members of any of our training programmes and courses can log in here:
    The Property Investor's Handbook
    The Buy-to-Let Masterclass

    PROPERTY INVESTMENTS UK

    Westminster House,
    10 Westminster Road,
    Macclesfield.
    SK10 1BX

    Company Number: 08852962
    VAT Number: 293 4194 80

    rob@propertyinvestmentsuk.co.uk

    DISCLAIMER

    Property investing, like any investment, carries risks. It is important to note that results achieved in property, from following our training courses may vary from user to user.

    For full details, disclaimer and policies click here.
    To contact us click here.

    MEMBER OF
    member-the-property-ombudsman

    Partnered with

    Property XYZ logo

    © 2021 - Property Investments UK - All Rights Reserved

    Sitemap